Since the advent of closed rhinoplasty, a debate “rhinoplasty – open vs closed approach’ is a real thing. Specialists and patients alike discuss this issue for years now. So – is there a definite answer? Most probably not but it won’t prevent us from presenting you the pros and cons of both open rhinoplasty and closed rhinoplasty approaches and let you decide on your own.
An open rhinoplasty operation is a classic approach to a nose job. In it, doctors perform an incision across the columella – part of the nose separating nostrils. Then, they pull the skin of the nose up, uncovering the cartilage and bone. Later on, as in all types of rhinoplasty surgery, they remove, replace or place cartilage according to the patient’s wish. As for the open rhinoplasty recovery, it doesn’t vary much from the closed one.
What Are the Pros of Open Rhinoplasty?
It is a classical type of nose job. Hence, many doctors are able to conduct it successfully, assuming that they have also a good sense of aesthetics. Moreover, removing the skin in open rhinoplasty allows the specialists to see all parts of the nose. Therefore, they can perform the procedure without much damage to the nose and have a holistic view of their work. As a result, the accuracy achieved in open rhinoplasty is incomparable to a closed rhinoplasty surgery.
What Are the Cons of Open Rhinoplasty?
The only obvious disadvantage of open rhinoplasty is a possible open rhinoplasty scar. However, its position (under the nose) means that it isn’t really visible. Additionally, in many people the open rhinoplasty scar fades with time, leaving close to no trace. Still, it is often recalled in discussions regarding the open and closed rhinoplasty difference.
Nevertheless, remember that in open rhinoplasty, incision healing doesn’t take long as compared to the closed approach.
What Does Closed Rhinoplasty Surgery Involve?
The other side of the closed rhinoplasty vs open debate is the closed nose job. In it, doctors perform the procedure through incisions placed inside of one’s nose, hence, avoiding the external scarring. Apart from that, the procedure has similar aims and techniques involved. Doctors remove, replace, and place parts of cartilage and bone in order to reshape one’s nose. Moreover, closed rhinoplasty recovery doesn’t differ from the open one.
What Are the Pros?
The biggest advantage is with no doubt lack of visible scar. People who want to avoid any signs of having the nose job done usually prefer the closed nose rhinoplasty.
Additionally, the development in plastic surgery means that every year doctors become more and more successful in closed nose job. It can be only expected that in coming years their achievements will be even greater.
What Are the Cons?
Unfortunately, a closed nose job has many disadvantages. Due to the fact that doctors do not remove the nose skin, they cannot have a full view of one’s nose. More than that, they often inflict damage on nose cartilage, which may lead to complications or revision surgeries. Finally, this type of nose job grants smaller flexibility to the specialists.
So Which Method Is Best?
The open vs closed rhinoplasty discussion doesn’t have one definite answer. If you care about your nose looking perfect and avoid any damages to the cartilage, an open rhinoplasty is a choice for you. However, if you want to avoid the open rhinoplasty scar, a closed approach is for you. Regarding other aspects, there is no difference between closed and open rhinoplasty healing process, so it is not of our concern in this topic.
No matter the technique, do not forget that it is worth exploring both the options. Moreover, in today’s global world, you have a chance to save some money on the procedure. It is enough that you research the clinics abroad, in so-called medical tourism destinations such as Spain, India or Turkey.